Pictures & Graphics: GFX Battle - mcwoods Vs. Junior

Forgot to put in the Rule bit.. First to 5 Votes & votes must be with a small reason too! not just...

Junior takes it

I disagree with the others, Id say the opposite.

Woods is more simplistic which is why its more appealing, Juniors is more complex which makes it far to busy and confusing.

Woods, Id of picked a more readable font - yeah it might look good but if your doing an album cover you dont want the person stood there for half an hour trying to work out who it is - its not likely to they'll buy it - just give up an move to the next CD.
Also I would of dropped the city my self.


Junior - You seem to have a habbit of shoving as many logos as you can into your covers, most of those would normally go on the back of a CD wouldnt they? (eg Compact Disc and label etc) - Also Im not feelin the stars you dont notice them but they make the cover to "busy" and the "Sway" part doesnt blend well IMO, it feels disconnected and a different style to the rest of the cover - maybe changing the gradient colour

Though it doesnt relate directly to the battle - I would say Junoir that you seem to be having problems picking the right colours as of late, your older sigs are alot better IMO than your newer ones (take your current for example - a hideous blue)


Vote: Woods


(PS this should of gone in the Graphics forum - as I've mentioned in the past, "Special Battles" is for Title matchs and 3-ways etc - if we get enough Gfx battles I may concider setting it up properly.)

fine - cry.

Vote retracted.


an you do realise that "Special Battles" comes before "Picures and Graphics" so threads there will be seen first? - an yeah Sages sig is dope - fact remains about your current and this though.

Thanks Ikon... Holla at me if you want that cover too, i'm sure you can throw some idea's together..

Props Woods.. Keep working on your skills and you'll soon be turning out "professional looking" stuff too...

Pretty one sided as i expected tbh

Woods - Not bad at all for a first try but as already been pointed out its very plain and not blended well, i liked the idea you had for the design but it needed better execution, also the fonts were very plain and poor choices im guessing thats because your working with the basic fonts?....If you wanna carry on doing gfx which id say to since its a great time waster, look into downloading better fonts as the titles and style of title add alot to any gfx.

Junior - This was nice, i always have the same problems with your designs tho as i explained to you on msn, one thing i dislike (still) is the text but i agree with what you said about it being hard to work with so u worked it well with what you had, there was also too much going on, i liked the general design of the cover with the stars and shit, and glad u chose sway (dude don't get the respect he deserves) design looked professional though i would of changed a few bits, it was generally nice

Vote - Junior